Wednesday, May 13, 2015

Survivor 30: Worlds Apart: Goat Island



“On the plains of hesitation bleach the bones of countless millions who, at the dawn of decision, sat down to wait, and waiting died.”
--Sam Ewing

“The worst calamities that befall an army arise from hesitation.”
--Sun Tzu

In retrospect, we should have all seen it coming.

With every passing week, we waited for Tyler to make the bold move that would change the game.

Just after the merge, while Rodney pounded on his chest like a gorilla and shouted at his tribe mates in his unintelligible Boston accent, Tyler sat quietly to the side, staring thoughtfully into the fire.

It was a good time to make a move to eliminate Rodney.  Tyler did nothing. 

When the rudderless and fractured no-Collars approached him to join forces in order to break up the powerful and cohesive blue collar 5, Tyler carefully pondered the offer.

It was the perfect time to set the power players into scramble mode and play out the rest of the game with a bunch of hippies.  Tyler demurred.

When Will freaked out and started verbally assaulting Shirin and Mike came to her defense, Tyler placed his chin in his hand and gazed ahead, considering these events as they unfolded.

The Survivor gods had granted him a second chance to make a move and finish with a numerical edge.  Tyler opted to stand pat.

Players bickered.  Tyler idled.

Contestants melted down.  Tyler pondered.

People made catastrophic gaffes.  Tyler hesitated.

Not yet....Not yet.....Not yet....Too late.


In the end, anyone with whom he might have done business was long gone, and Tyler’s fate rested firmly in the hands of people just smart enough to realize that Tyler (Mike having an idol and not subject to votes) was the least offensive person remaining in a tribe of obscenely offensive human beings.

The “as long as it ain’t me” ploy that led Sandra Diaz-Twine to 2 Survivor wins is all good and fine on tribes that do not consist of 2 viable players and 5 goats but this season it simply lands you in 7th place.

When all is said and done, Tyler will be remembered (if at all) as neither evil genius nor senseless dunderpate.

He’s just another nice guy who, frozen by risk aversion, spat in opportunity’s eye, left his fate in the hands of enemies, and then sat in judgement of lesser people.

As much as I hate to do it, I guess I’d better assign some sort of power rankings to these shmos:


#6:  Mike:

Mike has played brilliantly the last 2 weeks.  His idol bluff that proved to Dan that he was at or near the bottom of his alliance was pure gold.

Sadly, Dan is simply too dimwitted to recognize the obvious.

Mike is viewed as the greatest threat and is completely isolated.   Only by winning every remaining immunity challenge can he hope to get to the end.



#5: Carolyn

Our old friend Cochran once said that it is not the moves you make in Survivor but the timing thereof. 

Carolyn finds herself in one of the most problematic catch-22s I have ever seen on this show.

She is a challenge threat and has no clear enemies either on or off the jury.  Sitting next to this woman at final tribe would be an unmitigated disaster for anyone left in the game who does not drill oil for a living.  The band of goats left in the majority wants her out.  Badly.

Carolyn’s only viable path to the finals (aside from an epic challenge run) was to tie herself to Tyler, join up with Mike and Sierra, and then wipe out Dan.

Here’s the rub.  Carolyn cannot defeat either Tyler or Mike in a jury vote.  

So in order to make it to the end at all, she needed to go there with people who would certainly defeat her.



Like Tyler, Carolyn did not make any of the necessary big moves when the opportunity presented itself and then knocked out Tyler 2 moves too early.




#4) Sierra

The second this woman does anything interesting I am going to fall off my couch in shock.


#3) Dan

The only thing keeping Dan from the number 2 spot in the power rankings is the fact that the precise nature of his advantage will inevitably become known to the other players and he will become a target.

Under normal circumstances, this is not a huge concern for someone that everyone wants to take to the final 3 but Dan is pretty stupid.

Dan finally reveals his strategy behind the scenes





#2 Will:

This man may, in fact, be the greatest goat in Survivor history.

If I had the immunity necklace and had to choose between Will and…say….Kim Jong Un, I’m taking Will.

Phillip Shepherd (The specialist) was crazy.


Russel Hantz was sinister.


Colten Cumbie was mean spirited and digusting.



With his treatment of Shirin and subsequent refusal to either step back from his attack or apologize, he has effectively combined these traits into a single, flabby, asthmatic package.

Add to this unimpressive resume the fact that that middle-aged Sherri lady who nearly died of starvation in Fans vs. Favorites exhibited twice the endurance and athleticism of Will and you have yourself a fine goat.

Yep.  Will lacks the physical prowess of this woman.,


There is not a single possible scenario that results in this guy getting a million bucks.

In fact, I cannot imagine any jury composition in the history of this show that would result in either Dan or Will hoisting the million dollar check.

Will is making it to the end.  Bank on it.



#1 Rodney

Even as I type this, my fingers feel as if they might throw up.

Rodney’s primary virtue lay in the fact that he is the least reprehensible of the likely finalists and is just barely smart enough to know that he needs to get rid of Carolyn.

Let’s look at Boston Rod’s game by measuring him against the 3 primary aspects of a successful run:

1)      Strategy

--Rodney attempted to form 3 alliances outside the blue collar one into which he was initially thrust.  In his first try, Joaquin was voted out immediately.  In attempt #2, that cop lady got wiped immediately.  Now on #3, Rodney lost Tyler and will need to eliminate Carolyn soon.

His “I’m gonna quit” ploy didn’t fool anyone.

Essentially, everything this guy tried failed.  Fortunately for Rodney, he is the only one likely to make it to the end who actually tried to do anything.  A disaster on any other season, he played a better game in this respect that Sierra, Dan, or Will.

2)      Physical

--For a buff meathead, Rodney is a big candy-ass.

Still, nobody but Mike and Caroline can claim to have done any better and with Will having been lucky to have even survived he won’t be hurt too badly here.

3)      Social

--Boston Rod’s game consists of stomping around camp throwing tantrums and shouting expletives and insulting women.

This looks like social work compared to the idiocy of Will and Dan.

It boils down to one simple thing:

Rodney is the king of dipshits. 

The strongest goat. 

The least objectionable human being of the likely finalists.



If Mike or Carolyn do not win out in the immunity challenges, Rodney will win this game and then I will know that God hates people who watch Survivor.

No comments:

Post a Comment